Preloader Image
two women talking on a couch with plants in the background

How to Talk About AI Concerns: Navigating Difficult Conversations

By: Idealist Consulting
3 minutes

While some colleagues at your organization may be excited about AI, others may be concerned about the implications, and some may even feel that using AI at all betrays the mission. All of those reactions come from caring about the work, and honest conversations can help chart a path forward. 

For an in-depth look at a few common ethical and environmental concerns surrounding AI, including the latest research and perspectives on how nonprofits can approach them, download our full guide: Mission Aligned AI: A Guide for Nonprofit Leaders. 

Approaches that may help in starting conversations about AI

Start with values, not tools: Before debating any product, ask: "What do we care about, and what would AI need to look like to fit those values?" This shifts the conversation from "for or against" to "under what conditions”, and it also gives skeptics a real seat at the table.

Name the concern before answering it: People can't hear information while they feel dismissed, and a simple "you're right that this brings up real ethical concerns, and that matters" goes further than leading with statistics.

Take agency in how your organization uses AI: Your organization can't singlehandedly control the future of AI, but it can control which tools it uses, how often, for what, and what it asks of vendors. By focusing on what's in your hands, you may help turn staff anxiety into agency.

Be honest about uncertainty: You don't need to have every answer, but “the research is still evolving, and here's what we know so far" builds more trust than overconfidence in either direction.

Invite the people affected: It is incredibly important to not have top down AI adoption. Bring in the staff at the start of the conversation, and create an AI cohort that can help formulate how the tool is used at your organization and chart the path forward.  Not only does this give people the ability to advocate for themselves and others, it helps spot risks that leadership may miss.

You don't have to figure this out alone

Concern about AI's environmental and ethical costs isn't a reason to stop the conversation. In fact, it's an invitation to have a greater, more nuanced one. The organizations that handle AI well won't be the ones that adopted it the fastest or, on the flip side, refused it the longest. They'll be the ones that stayed honest, put their values first, and brought their people along.

Ready to move from conversation to action? In Mission Aligned AI: A Guide for Nonprofit Leaders, we share practical steps nonprofits can take when navigating responsible AI adoption, including a framework for evaluating AI tools and a checklist for responsible AI adoption. 

If you'd like help establishing the groundwork for AI adoption, or you'd just like to chat about how to navigate this new space, Idealist Consulting is here to help.